Conceptual ideas about human pathology in the
light of the working out approach to the pathogenetic
therapy.
According to the modern World public health
service society classification there are more than 30
000 independent nosologic forms (diseases). It is
inconceivable that each of these one's has its own
etiology (cause) and the more so its own independent
pathogenesis according to the nosologic form
determination.
In addition unification of the existing nosologic
one's according to the current dividing according to
subject headings is very conditionally. Variety of
diseases requiring multidisciplinary approach (for
example, hepatolenticular degeneration) accentuates
convention of that dividing to an even greater
degree.
These simple arguments can serve as base for
further reasoning and understanding main point of the
matter.
To tell the truth, diseases are realized by means
of strict determined and not numerous mechanisms
conditioned by the human nature granting the all
variety of etiologic factors.
To tell strict, the concept of pathogenesis is so
conditionally as existing dividing according to
subject headings. It is more correct to say about
reaction of organism as an effect of pathologic
situation within its physiologic opportunities. I.e.,
pathogenesis is protective reaction of organism as an
effect of external and internal factors exceeding the
level of physiologic admissibility. In this
connection, the concept of “pathogenesis”
is interaction of the pathologic factor and the
natural protection mechanisms including compensatory
ones.
One way or another, any pathologic process can be
realized on the following kinds:
- Harmful factor is too considerable and exceeds
the level of physiologic compensation. Or
compensatory possibilities are very weakened. The
result of this situation is death.
- Value of harmful factor doesn't exceed the
level of physiologic compensation. Compensatory
processes lead to the full compensation of the
pathologic process. The result of this situation is
recovery.
- Harmful factor gets on the organism at the
long-term trend and exhausts compensatory
possibilities. Or a pathologic agent can't be
compensated by the organism in full measure. In
this case some balance and chronometry of the
pathologic process in clinical picture come into
existence. Exactly this variant is of high our
interest, as the most so named somatic,
neurological diseases and after-actions of
craniocerebral injury, vascular catastrophe, etc.
assume a chronic character.
“DOCTOR NARYSHKIN'S GROUP” |
Leader: |
A.G.Naryshkin
high qualification's
category doctor
candidate (holder of
first higher degree, awarded on dissertation)
of medical sciences
Neurology,
Neurosurgery and Medical genetics department
senior lecturer at the St.-Petersburg
I.I.Metchnikov State Medical
Academy |
| |
|
Clinical base: |
Saint Petersburg Bekhterev scientific-research psychoneurological institute.
Senior research worker of the nervous und psychical diseases surgery department |
The actual Medicine task is to raise the living
quality of the sick within steady remission based on
the organism compensatory possibilities.
The tactical task is to provide early activation
of these compensatory possibilities, which begins at
the critical and the most critical disease's periods.
It permits to restrict a destroying effect of the
pathologic agent and to prevent a process
chronometry.
These two tasks are the foundation-stone of the
present wide developed methodology of recovery
treatment.
On the basis of these common ideas we have
developed and introduced into medicine practice and
used successfully a number of the methodological and
methodical approaches.
Vegetative nervous system
In our opinion, a role of the vegetative nervous
system (further as VNS) in
pathogenesis of so named internal diseases is not
assessed in full measure at the present moment. The
most, what modern specialists discuss, is the role of
VNS as premorbid background. Meanwhile, balanced VNS
state is responsible for a functional state of all
internal organs, what is the base of health.
We think, disbalance in VNS is the basis of
practically any somatic disease. We understand under
concept “disbalance” as the most simply
and sympathetic and parasympathetic link of VNS or
oppression one of them.
The following important moment of internal organs
pathology understanding is an excitation focus and
oppression focus existence within VNS and a wide
irradiation of this state opportunity within
practically the all VNS. Exactly this fact has a
solution of many difficult to understand signs of
diseases. This is indeed, VNS structure is based and
realized on the “net” principle. Any VNS
department is closely connected with another definite
removed part of the system.
It is essential to indicate, that a reticular
formation of the brain trunk on its all levels
including cellular one has an essential resemblance
with the peripheric VNS structure. The reticular
formation of the brain trunk simultaneous is an
equal, in the brain placed department of the
peripheric VNS structure. At that, when we say: VNS
has central regulation's role, it means: it's
misestimated. Most probably it executes connection's
function between the peripheric VNS and the brain
both in afferent meaning and in efferent meaning.
In our opinion, the VNS coordinating and
regulating centre and is heavy accumulation of
vegetative neuron placing in the celiac plexus.
It is well-known that a number of neurons in the
celiac plexus exceeds a number of neurons in the
brain. According to the phylogenetic theory the
celiac plexus is an analogue of a ancient
“abdominal” brain, which have interior
classes of animals.
At that, the neurons of vegetative ganglions are
exported to the peripheric sphere. And they have not
special protective barriers in contrast to central
neurons. Therefore any endured harmfulness
(infection, intoxication, trauma, etc. and external
medium change and its negative factors) has influence
on the neurons and leaves indelible traces. In this
case the matter is about vegetative memory of the
organism. This memory fixes so as brain the all
actions of the organism internal medium.
It is necessary to note that the vegetative
ganglions are original neuroendocrinal formation
producing a lot of neuromediators, endorphins and
hormone similar substances too. Therefore any
important modifications in the VNS activity are
accompanied by important modifications in the
mediator endocrine background of the organism. These
modifications affect on the functional activity of
the internal organs and can bring to disease's
development by concurrence of definite
circumstances.
Taking into account the above named it is
impossible to say about pathology of any organ. The
pathology is determined by organism's available
predispositions showing in medicine well-known
principle “Locus minoris
resistentia”.
In this connection it is necessary to take into
account the possibility of VNS segmental disbalance.
If this segment falls outside the controls of the VNS
control regulating departments (celiac plexus), the
developing disfunction of the segment managing organ
bring to morphologic disturbances some time or other.
However even by the essential affection of the organ
a balanced vegetative management has ability to
reconstruct its functional abilities. This fact
determines the scope of medicinal tactics aimed at
the VNS regulation within the bounds of the earliest
prevention of morphologic disturbances and of
influence to the organ's function even by formed
secondary morphologic disturbances.
Clinic diagnostic of a vegetative disfunction is
effected considerably easy according to the methods
developed by Academician Markelov. At that
painfulness of solar ganglia and index of vegetative
irritation are determined.
On the face of it painfulness of solar ganglia by
the VNS pathology is paradoxically according to the
above named. However there is not antinomy, as the
VNS is built by the principle of the syncytium with a
lot of short and long reverberated ansae having both
afferent and efferent arms. Therefore coordinating
role of solar ganglia in the VNS function can combine
with their secondary disfunction caused by distant
irritation focus.
To understand this moment is necessary to depart
from the ranking principle in VNS building and
activity. That can be so named as rights equality of
the all VNS departments by the coordinating role of
celiac plexus.
It is necessary to discuss the role of the brain
in the regulation of the vegetative functions
special. At one time the ideas of nervosism advanced
by Academician I.P.Pavlov were developed in the
workers of Academicians Bykov, Kurzin, Tchernigovsky.
They proved the regulated influence of brain to the
vegetative functions.
At the same time Academicians Orbeli and Markelov
proved the ability of opposite interactions, i.e.
powerful influence of the VNS to activity of the
whole Central Nervous system (further as CNS). It is
considerably to recall that the volume of incoming
into brain vegetative afferentation is a considerable
part of the all afferent flow managing direct
functional state of brain.
Therefore, the question is about inter-added
influences. This fact is allowed to reject the thesis
about managed influence CNS to VNS as unilateral
ones.
Certainly, an animal has begin of gastric juice
secretion process, when it sees food. On the other
hand an animal behaves so complex to see food
according to the vegetative action of
“hungry” stomach. Thus it is difficult to
determine the leading link in interaction between CNS
and VNS.
Therefore it is possible to influence to the CNS
activity considerable.
The concrete embodiment of the above mentioned
ideas is methods of electrical impacts to the celiac
plexus. These methods are used by us in practice with
success. We get considerable, long improvement and
sometimes recovery of diseased for a long time (terms
of anamnesis to 25 years, diagnosis:
“Diencephalic syndrome”) patients,
diseased patients with so named vegetovascular
dystonia and any states caused by the first brain
affection, particularly parkinsonism and any forms of
epileptic fits with a help of these methods. We have
good, encouraging results of theses methods by
treatment some internal and even dermal (psoriasis)
diseases. There can be no doubt that this direction
has grand perspective.
Fundamental importance of afferent
flows mismatch in pathogenesis of motor
disturbances.
The role is not estimated at its true worth the
correct role of the afferent flows in organisation's
activity of the whole of the CNS and particularly of
the brain. The question is about a dominant meaning
of the nervosism ideas. These ideas were determined
and understood incorrect previously. The brain had
the special attitude as a organ of reflective and
mental activity. Hence is the idea that the brain has
the leading and managing role.
At the same time, the brain is an organ operating
according to strict determined mechanisms aimed the
basic task - reflection. Hence we understand that the
brain activity is determined and managed according to
its reflected and afferent formations. The posterior
departments: temporal, visual and parietal cortexes
belong to these formations. At that the brain is
divided in two parts. There is a posterior receiving
part and a anterior using part. Although this scheme
is conditional as there is independent, anterior
somatosensory area in the frontal lobe of the brain.
This fact confirms improbable compensatory
possibilities of the brain. At that the question, the
anterior somatosensory area provides afferent
functions by the damage of the brain posterior
departments.
The development of the brain begins from its
posterior departments and follows into front
direction in the ontogenesis and phylogenesis. The
frontal lobes are mature as last ones, to the mature
age of an organism. It evidences of the importance of
the brain posterior departments in the process of
information getting and mature of the brain.
It is very important to say that a human being can
not active or operate without a correct organized
affected synthesis. In this connection any
disorganization can bring to gross errors of the
brain activity.
According to the modern methods of neurology the
motor function can be damaged basic by destruction of
the motor centers. At that the afferent paresis
connected with sensor conduction tract's and cortex
departments affection is possible. Modern
neurologists explain that fact as a reflex arch. And
the mechanism of the several motor affections is
enigma. Modern medicine tries to find their
biochemical substratum. This way brings to the
confusion of this question. If the Levo-Dop's
compound helps diseased patient with Parkinsonism, it
doesn't mean that disturbance of a dophaminergical
transfer is a pathophysiological base of this
disease. In this situation pathophysiological
mechanisms and pathogenic causes are confused and
brought to the one denominator. This confusion brings
to destructive tendencies in the medicine and loses
its internal logic.
On the base of the long cervical dystonia
treatment experience we prove that pathophysiological
base of the disease is afferent flows mismatch. We
mean treatment diseases with affection of posture
support function with the help of the methods of transtympanal chemical vestibular
dereception (further as TTCVD ) and with the help of
estimation of functional state of the brain by the
methods of computing electroencephalogram (EEG).
With the aim to support posture the following
kinds of afferentation take part: vestibular,
proprioceptive, visual ones and a common afferent
flow. Their activity and interactivity are strict
coordinated on many levels of the brain. The leading
level is thalamus.
We are sure that the base pathophysiological
mechanism of this function affection is a mismatch of vestibular and proprioceptive
afferent flows .
The TTCVD method is feasible as pathophysiological
one and so high effective.
On the base of our ideas of the motor affections
pathogenesis we use the TTCVD method as a treatment
method by many CNS diseases.
This method is high effective for patients with
spastic gemi-, para-, tetraparesis. It brings to
considerable reduction of muscular tonus, expansion
of motor abilities, increase power, reduction of
disturbances.
In the cause of the Parkinsonism we have the fact
of reduction of muscular tonus to the normotonie,
reduction of disturbances, propulsions, oligo- and
bradykinesia, hypomimia and according vegetative
disturbances.
Therefore, the practice provides that the
mechanism of afferent flows mismatch is base of these
diseases.
There are the following necessary and sufficient
conditions for coordination of afferent flows in the
normal position:
- timely receiving heteromodal impulses to
neuron;
- balance of their characteristics;
- readiness of the neuron to impulses
integration.
As a result of the coordination of afferent
impulses in neurons of relay and associative nuclei
(mainly, thalamic ones) the cortex gets a impulse
having synthetic information with common
characteristics of heteromodal signals.
The phenomenon of flows mismatch can be in the
following situations:
- divergence of the heteromodal impulses incoming
in time;
- excess or deficient capacity of a impulse;
- non-readiness of the neuron to the synthetic
activity.
This situation can be determined under influences
of neurons of other brain structures.
Particularly, we think, that striopallidal system
and caudate nucleus execute the such modulator's
function to the associative nuclei of the thalamus.
So can be explained many clinical displays of so
named diseases of basal ganglia system.
Relative excessiveness of the
afferent flows as a base of intelligent-mnestical
disturbances
We have the opinion that by gross organic brain
affections with irreversible disturbances of the full
neuronal complexes functions the brain is in the
state of afferent overload. The common number of
afferent information doesn't conform to its detector
possibility.
Such situation can cause various kinds of
neurological and even psychoneurological
symptomatology. It is logical to suppose that the
switching off one of the powerful afferent flows
reduces the sensory loading on the brain and makes
simply the other information including semantic
important one's processing. These processes bring to
the clinical recovery.
On our opinion, the base afferent flow is
vestibular flow. The vestibular sensibility is the
most old according to the phylogenetics. It is true
that any human being is always under influence of
gravitational field of the Earth. The most ancient
forms of organisms had special mechanisms of
gravitational vector's indication.
During the evolution the new sensory forms were
overbuilt to this basic reception.
The all sensory kinds are structural organized and
coordinated on the base of this main vestibular
reception. This fact gets this reception the main and
leading importance. Therefore, we think that the
above mentioned kind of afferention is in the lead of
information flows incoming into the brain, as it
takes part in the all forms of specified
afferention.
As several patients with cervical dystonia gets
facilitation, extraction and reproduction of long
memory traces as a result of the TTCVD method using
and at that the switching off of vestibular reception
doesn't bring to invalidated effects, we‘ve
used this method by the several kinds of memory
disturbances and got a steady positive effect. There
is large subjective and objective memory improvement,
normalization of psychoemotional disturbances by
patients with psychoorganic and Korsakov's syndromes
too. These processes bring to the full medical
rehabilitation and social readaptation.
Problem of the brain focal
destruction
Vascular diseases of the
brain and craniocerebral injury can be become
complicated by the development of sharp affections
may be in chronic form and with steady neurological
deficit.
The main task is the focus minimization,
particularly its expansion stopping and the earliest
inclusion of perifocal zones.
By the chronic focus there are zones of brain
tissue being in the state of the parabiosis. The aim
of the recovering treatment is to activate these
zones and to include other cortex parts to the
affected functions. The last task can be solved by
the complexes methods.
At the last time we developed effective the
methods of transcranial
microelectropolarization - TCMEP . As the
results of this method using we provide ability of
focus expansion and perifocal edema stopping,
resorption processes speeding up.
These effects correspond to the tasks. As a result
the terms of recovering shorten twice. Many patients
evade surgical intervention.
This method using allows getting considerable
results by the effects of the sharp brain
catastrophes with steady neurological deficit for the
period of 2-3 months and more. In our day-to-day work
this method is a part of the complex of the recovery
treatment's measures. This complex contents of the
above mentioned TTCVD method, FBM (functional
biomanagement)method, NDM (neurodynamic management based on the ACFC-2
phenomena). The complexity using gets the best
results.
Problem of the patients with
“small consciousness”
One of the negative results of craniocerebral
injury is incoming of the patient into so named
“small consciousness”. The vegetative
state, akinetic muthism belong to this “small
consciousness”. These states are characterized
by absence of connection with an external world and
by the full absence of any movements with increasing
of the muscular tonus on the flexion type. That can
be brought to development of articular contractures.
This category of patients hasn't many perspectives.
At the present time the modern medicine doesn't know
any treatment's methods and relies up on the time
factor. The main such patients are lost as a result
of connected somatic complications.
The concrete substratum of these states is long
parabiotic state of numerous areas of the brain
cortex. The earliest and active treatment tactics are
directed to the activization of the brain cortex
activity and to minimization of the sensory afferent
flows. In addition it is necessary to use actions
directed to the muscular tonus reduction.
In the connection with the above mentioned we've
developed the original complex treatment methods for
these heavy categories of the patients. Taking into
account the mechanism of micro polarization it is
necessary to use these methods.
The positive results allow hoping the wide
development of this method. We can note the quick
(2-3 weeks) activation of such patients, the muscular
tonus reduction, the spontaneous movement activity
expansion, features of self-service (min.
self-swallowing), elementary speech contact by speech
cortex zones support. This clinical dynamic are
accompanied by positive dynamic of EEG. Our results
are basis for development of this method further
on.
Problem of DAI
The syndrome of diffusive axonal injury
(DAI) belongs to the category of
craniocerebral injury and can realizes in two
principle ways: the first - with the brain trunk
lesion, the second - with the partial brain
hemispheres lesion. The practice shows that by the
partial brain hemispheres lesion their mediobazal
departments are damaged. In this case the treatment
terms are very long and the final result can be
unforeseen. At the present time the modern medicine
doesn't know effective treatment's methods and relies
up on the time factor.
By the brain hemispheres lesion diagnostics the
leading position has EEG.
We suggest the new methods presenting the above
mentioned TTCVD method of the mediobazal and brain
trunk structures. These methods can recovery the
patients within 2-3 weeks, allows restoring the
patient to health in their intellectual ability and
activity, to shorten the treatment terms. There are
positive changes in electric diagnostics.
Summary
Thus, the stored by us material is singular choice
in the understanding and treatment of many heavy
brain lesions. As a result of our recognition there
are original conceptions of the pathophysiological
mechanisms of the brain and the high effective
methods being as a choice to medicamental and
medicosurgical treatments.
The basic advantage of these methods is their
simplicity, small expenditure and invasiveness and
safety.
The suggested methods are the first methods. They
can be the base for establishment the concrete
direction of the recovery medicine. We intend to
follow our development in this medical area further
on.
Russia, St.-Petersburg, 2004 |